There have been many comparisons of the various messaging clients available
today: Google Talk, Yahoo Messenger, MSN Messenger, AOL Instant Messenger
and hybrid ones as well, such as Trillian. These studies usually do a
good job at comparing the features offered by these clients, but for some
strange reason, I have yet to find one that really nails the one thing that
makes the difference for me with Google Talk: presence ubiquity.
Throughout the day, I typically move between three or four different PC’s
(work, laptop, home, etc…) and this particular feature means that not only do
I not need to log on constantly, it also means that I can start a conversation
home and finish it at work without having to do anything. The logic behind
the message broadcasts is sometimes a bit mysterious, but it works most of the
time and is a joy for computer vagabonds like myself.
Since no article ever mentioned this feature, I am guessing
my situation is pretty unusual, but since it’s the only one that only exists in
Google Talk, I am stunned that it hasn’t been emulated by any other client.
Having said that, I do agree that Google Talk is very
austere and I have to confess an unending fondness for Yahoo’s cute smileys, but
presence ubiquity is the main reason why my Friends List on Google Talk
keeps getting bigger why my Yahoo’s Buddy List has been stagnant for over a year
now. People who need to reach me now know that Google Talk is the first
client to try. If they don’t know where I am, Google Talk certainly does.
Of course, the fact that Yahoo keeps
nagging me about
upgrading without giving me a chance to opt out and that it will change my
home page if I’m not careful during the installation doesn’t help.
It could be worse, though: you could install AOL Instant Messenger and
spend the next ten minutes hunting down and killing all the "Free AOL" shortcuts
that suddenly pop up in unexpected places on your desktop. I
hear their latest experimental version, codenamed Triton, goes even further and
changes your home page, installs Plaxo, a toolbar and a modified full-screen version of IE that
lands on their page. Oh and you can’t refuse the installation of this
software: you will need to uninstall it by hand later.
That’s clearly not "not evil".
I feel some comfort thinking that Google Talk uses open standards and doesn’t
come with any additional baggage, but I wouldn’t mind if it added some of the
bells and whistles found in its competitors. How about them smileys for a start,
?
#1 by Balazs Fejes on January 24, 2006 - 1:18 pm
The other day I was trying to find some info on getting WLS 9 working on OSX. I’ve checked if Rod Chavez (from BEA) ever did a followup to his old WLS 8.1 article on O’ReillyNet. After some digging I realized that he is now working on Google Talk…
#2 by RichB on January 24, 2006 - 3:11 pm
GTalk seems to keep friends as “Available” when they’re clearly not available. For example – I’m currently sat on a train using web/GTalk over GPRS. I’ve left a friend at the bar, yet his presence says “Available”.
Also, when I set my message to “On Train” during the morning commute, and then to “@work” (laptop to desktop), it takes someone to actually send a message before their client realizes to change their message. I’ve had people say to me “long train journey???”
I’ve submitted (and helped fix) bugs in GTalk, but these are such ephemeral bugs, it’s difficult to create a succinct bug report.
#3 by Kevin on January 24, 2006 - 3:44 pm
There is nothing to compare with having a conversation that crosses three or four computers and maintains context for both or all parties. Of all the things that came out of jabber.org/com, that has to be high on the list of great ideas.
That said, I have been told by some very smart people, that presence ubiquity is not to be taken seriously. For one of these people, it was the very definition of why “our company would never use an XMPP (Jabber based) product. XMPP will loose out in the messaging war, and you (me) will be amongst the people who have to reimplement. Just plain stupid.”
These very same smart people all use gtalk now. Go figure 🙂
#4 by Rodolphe on January 25, 2006 - 8:31 am
> How about them smileys for a start, ?
http://www.projetobms.net/GTPlug.php?pagina=pj&lang=en
#5 by Keith Lea on January 25, 2006 - 9:04 am
AOL Instant Messenger allows you to sign on from multiple computers. Is this what you mean?
#6 by Bill Kress on January 26, 2006 - 9:53 am
I’ve been pretty furious with Yahoo’s invasiveness lately, espically the toolbar they keep wanting to install, but it sounds like AOL has beat them at their own game.
Maybe I will move to google–I tried it at first and it was just not very impressive, but give ’em a few more months and I’m sure they will come out on top as usual.
Umm, looks like the last firefox upgrade disabled spellbound, so I’ll go ahead an apologize for any spelling errors…
#7 by Gaurav Chawla on January 26, 2006 - 6:37 pm
The only reason I use gtalk is because its voice features. Other than that, yahoo msg beats gtalk hands down. I only upgrade yahoo when there are some useful features in the next release. About invasive s/w, have you seen JDK? It constantly asks me to upgrade with the annoying bubble in the system tray even though I have the latest JDK installed. There is no option to not remind me later. To me, system tray is just untouchable territory. I don’t like if some small pesky application has a presence there. It should be only used by apps which run all day but you don’t want them to be shown all the time.
#8 by Josh on January 31, 2006 - 2:45 pm
Perhaps one of the reasons articles on GTalk miss this feature is that it appears to not really be talked about… which is to say, there is nothing about it on GTalk homepage, or on the about page, or on the getting started page, and possibly not in the help section either though i haven’t waded through it all. Of course it could just be I’m missing it somewhere.
#9 by Victor Ott on February 7, 2006 - 12:05 am
Gaurav, I bet you have the latest JDK installed, but that doesn’t mean the latest JRE is installed and active too… Maybe it was not installed, or, another software you installed was bundled with a older JRE release and has overridden at install the JRE settings. Several JRE’s can coexist together, but the last installed one is the “default” one. If I’m permitted, I’d suggest you crosscheck the update settings in “ContolPanel > Java”. In “ControlPanel > Add & Remove Programs” (in some internationalised versions called “> Software”) you could take look to see exactly which JDK and JRE versions are installed. To find out which version is the “default” one, try “java -version” in a command prompt window. Hope this helps.
#10 by ray007 on February 9, 2006 - 1:09 am
Jabber protocol simply supports this nice presence ubiquity feature, and it has been around for years. Why everything once picked up by google will become a phenomenon?
I love gtalk for its light-weighted packaging and integration with GMail, nice voice quality. I wish the video will be out soon.
Obviously, GTalk uses the same voice codec as Skype .
#11 by alooshi on July 8, 2006 - 9:02 am
what is this website
#12 by Gaurav Gathania on March 1, 2007 - 9:18 am
Hey Guys,
As u people hav been discussing abt Gtalk and somebuddy mentioned tht he has been using gtalk via GPRS….can u suggest me someclient that i can use for my phone too i.e some Java app. or something like tht ..no symbian apps ..as i got a Ming(Motorola A1200)
#13 by buyutucukrem on January 2, 2008 - 1:53 am
Erotik Seks Shop Market Cinsel Sağlık
#14 by John Ulmer on December 4, 2008 - 7:25 pm
On Jan 24, 2006 Cedric wrote about seamlessly moving between different computers with gtalk. I would like to do this on my home & work computers so anyone can gtalk me wherever I happen to be. How do I setup gtalk on the two computers to make this possible?
#15 by bikash agarwal on February 9, 2009 - 11:54 am
hi………
as i m student of b.tech in computer science and i wnt to create my own IM service like yahoo messeger or gtalk so for these what should i first plzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz help me out
i m desperate about my work plz help meeeeeeeeeeee